Apron Finish

I made this fun apron recently. I love the fabric even though its not my usual box of crayons. I may have to make one just like it for myself. I really love that HUGE Ric Rac.
Its reversible and I used the Church Lady Apron pattern by Mary's Productions and the fabric I believe is called Marrakesh, by Blank textiles.

What to Do?

I am needing some advice regarding a little quilt swap. I'm participating in round 4 (I think its 4) of a doll quilt swap on about.com quilting forum. I have attempted to make a Lone Star in miniature for my partner. I worked really hard on this, and took it apart more times than I care to mention. Still, I have lost 3 of the 8 star points. Now, I don't know if I should finish it and send it, or finish it and keep it as it has missing points.
Please tell me what you think, be brutally honest here please.
Here it is. I think if you click on the picture you can see it larger in webshots.